DENVER (AP) — Two Denver police officers won’t face charges in the fatal shooting of a 17-year-old girl driving a stolen car in January, and the teen was to blame because she ignored officers’ orders, the city’s district attorney said Friday.
Jessica Hernandez drove dangerously close to Officers Gabriel Jordan and Daniel Greene, threatening Jordan’s life and refusing orders to get out of the car, Mitch Morrissey wrote in a letter to Denver police explaining his decision not to prosecute.
“If there is one message I hope our community understands from this case, it is that this shooting was completely preventable,” Morrissey wrote. “It would not have occurred if Hernandez had simply complied with lawful police orders.”
A call to a lawyer representing Hernandez’s family was not immediately returned.
The Jan. 26 shooting sparked angry protests and followed racially charged killings by police elsewhere. On Friday, the American Civil Liberties Union of Colorado called for an independent review of Hernandez’s shooting, saying that Morrissey’s work with police as a prosecutor constituted a conflict of interest.
It also was the fourth time in seven months that Denver officers fired into a moving vehicle, and the department said in a statement that it continues to review its policies related to that practice.
The officers are now on desk duty. The department said its internal review of the shooting continues.
The officers told investigators they were investigating a report of a suspicious vehicle and that they shot Hernandez after she drove a stolen Honda Civic toward them in a residential alley. Four other teens were in the car, sleeping after a night out. None were injured.
Greene had pulled up behind the Honda, and Jordan pulled up in front. They both drew their weapons and ordered the teens out of the car. Instead, Hernandez slowly backed into Greene’s patrol car, then drove slowly toward Jordan, according to the officers’ accounts contained in Morrissey’s letter.
Hernandez reversed again, hit a fence and then accelerated forward toward Jordan, who said the car was so close he pushed it with his hand. The officers fired eight shots into the Honda, hitting Hernandez three times.
Photos from the scene showed the car with bullet holes in the driver’s side window and windshield.
“This begs the question of why Hernandez chose to not comply with those orders,” Morrissey wrote. “Perhaps she feared being caught driving a stolen car. Perhaps her judgment was impaired by marijuana and alcohol. … What is clear from the facts and needs no inference is that her decisions created a very dangerous situation, not just to herself and to the officers, but also to her friends who were in the car with her.”
An autopsy report showed Hernandez had marijuana and a small amount of alcohol in her system. Investigators found open bottles of alcohol and a marijuana pipe in the car.
Community anguish after the shooting was compounded by conflicting information about what happened. Police Chief Robert White initially said Jordan was hit in the leg by the car — then said Jordan may have been hurt trying to get out of the way.
Jordan told investigators that he didn’t remember the car hitting him, and doctors said he suffered a possible fracture, but not by being struck.
Soon after the shooting, a passenger in the car, speaking to The Associated Press on condition of anonymity because of safety concerns, disputed the official account of the shooting, saying officers didn’t yell commands and Hernandez likely lost control of the vehicle because she was shot and was unconscious.
But according to Morrissey, the car’s passengers told investigators that Hernandez started the car even as she could see the officers with guns drawn and hear them yelling, “Put your hands up!” One passenger said Hernandez’s friends were screaming for her to drive away and that she probably didn’t mean to hit the officer.